Kitchen Tips

10 Types of Crab Sauce: King Crab and Stone Crab

Welcome to a feast where the ocean meets the plate. At George Stone Crab, we're all about celebrating the rich, bold flavors that only the sea can offer — especially when it comes to crab. 

King Crab and Stone Crab stand as the jewels of the ocean, each bringing a unique taste and texture to the table. But what truly sets these dishes apart is the sauce. A good sauce doesn't just complement the crab but elevates it, turning a simple meal into a culinary experience. 

Join us as we dive into the world of crab sauces, exploring how to match these marine delights with their perfect pairings.

Why Is Sauce Important for Crab Dishes?

Sauce is more than just a sidekick to crab — it's a key player that can make or break a dish. 

Here's why:

  • Enhances Flavor: A well-crafted sauce can accentuate the natural sweetness of crab meat, adding layers of flavor that make each bite more complex and enjoyable.
  • Adds Moisture: Crab, especially when steamed or boiled, benefits from the moisture that sauces provide, ensuring the meat remains juicy and succulent.
  • Introduces Variety: From tangy to sweet, spicy to creamy, sauces can transform the same crab dish into a myriad of different culinary experiences, preventing palate fatigue.
  • Aesthetic Appeal: A drizzle or dollop of sauce can dramatically improve the presentation of a crab dish, making it as pleasing to the eye as it is to the taste buds.

What Makes a Crab Sauce Stand Out?

A standout crab sauce is much more than a mere accompaniment. It mesmerizes with its unique qualities and perfectly complements the crab's flavors. 

Here are a few factors that set exceptional crab sauces apart:

Complementary Flavors

The best sauces enhance, not overpower, the delicate taste of crab. They bring out the seafood's natural sweetness or offer a contrasting flavor profile that adds depth to the dish.


Whether it’s a silky smooth butter sauce or a chunky salsa, the texture of the sauce can add an interesting dimension to the crab dish, providing a delightful contrast to the tender meat.

Fresh Ingredients

Just like our fresh Stone Crab Claws, the best sauces are made from fresh, high-quality ingredients. Herbs, spices, and other components should be chosen carefully to ensure they elevate the overall dish.

Innovation and Tradition

While classic sauces have their place, don't be afraid to experiment. A unique sauce can turn a traditional crab meal into something extraordinary, offering a memorable dining experience.

Exploring the World of Crab Sauces

Diving into the world of crab sauces is like setting sail on a culinary adventure. There's a sea of flavors out there, each with the power to transform your crab feast into an unforgettable dining experience. 

From the classic to the contemporary, sauces are the unsung heroes of the seafood world. Let's navigate through some of the most beloved sauces that pair perfectly with the king of the crustaceans and the stone of the sea.

1. Classic Melted Butter

Is there anything more timeless than melted butter with crab? It's the quintessential pairing that respects the crab's natural flavor, enhancing it without overshadowing its delicate sweetness.

Warm your butter and add a pinch of sea salt and a squeeze of fresh lemon to brighten it up. Perfect for dipping those tender pieces of King Crab and Stone Crab, letting the succulence truly shine.

2. Zesty Lemon Garlic Butter

Taking the classic butter sauce up a notch, this sauce combines the zing of lemon and the aromatic punch of garlic, adding layers of flavor that complement the crab meat wonderfully.

Ideal for drizzling over steamed King Crab legs or Stone Crab claws, this sauce adds a burst of flavor that's both refreshing and rich.

3. Spicy Mustard Sauce

For those who prefer their crab with a bit of kick, a spicy mustard sauce offers a tangy and slightly fiery alternative. Its creamy texture and bold flavors are a match made in heaven for crab.

Our own take on this classic includes a blend of the best mustard and the richest mayonnaise — plus a few secret ingredients for that extra zing. It's a hit with Stone Crab claws, providing a contrast that's both creamy and satisfying.

4. Tangy Mango Salsa

This sauce combines the tropical sweetness of mango with the bite of red onion, the warmth of jalapeños, and the tang of lime juice, creating a multi-dimensional flavor profile that's as lively as it is luscious.

The sweetness and acidity cut through the richness of the crab, making it a perfect companion for both King Crab and Stone Crab. Serve on the side for a fresh, fruity complement that'll whisk you away to tropical shores.

5. Creamy Avocado Cilantro Sauce

A velvety blend of ripe avocados, fresh cilantro, lime juice, and a hint of garlic creates a sauce that's both rich and refreshing. Its creamy texture and vibrant flavors are a refreshing departure from the traditional.

Spoon over chilled Stone Crab claws for a summer-ready dish, or use it as a dipping sauce to add a creamy, zesty kick to King Crab segments.

6. Rich and Smoky Chipotle Aioli

For those who love a smoky twist, chipotle aioli offers a rich, creamy base with a deep, smoky undertone and just the right amount of heat. It's a bold choice that stands up to the robust flavors of crab.

Slather on King Crab legs before grilling for a smoky finish, or serve alongside Stone Crab claws for a dipping experience that packs a punch.

7. Old Bay Remoulade

A nod to seaside traditions, this remoulade mixes the zest of Old Bay seasoning with the creamy tanginess of mayonnaise, mustard, and a dash of hot sauce. It’s like a beach day for your taste buds.

Slather this on a crab cake made from tender Stone Crab meat, or use it as a bold dip for King Crab fingers. It’s a surefire way to add some Eastern Seaboard swagger to your meal.

8. Sweet Chili Lime Glaze

This glaze brings a perfect balance of sweetness from the chili sauce and a zesty kick from fresh lime juice, with a hint of garlic to round it out. It's sunshine and spice bottled up.

Brush this vibrant glaze over grilled King Crab legs for a caramelized finish, or toss Stone Crab claws in it for a sticky, sweet, and slightly spicy treat. It’s a game changer for those who like their seafood with a side of excitement.

9. Cucumber Dill Yogurt Sauce

This sauce is a breath of fresh air, combining the coolness of cucumber with the light, anise-like taste of dill and the creamy base of Greek yogurt. It’s like diving into a crisp, cool ocean wave.

Perfect for dolloping on top of a Stone Crab salad or as a refreshing dipping sauce for warm King Crab. It’s a hit for those balmy evenings when you want something that whispers rather than shouts.

10. Herby Lemon-Basil Aioli

Just when you thought we’d covered all the bases, in sails Herby Lemon-Basil Aioli. Imagine the zest of lemon meeting the aromatic charm of basil whipped into a light, creamy aioli. It's like a cool breeze on a hot summer day, refreshing and invigorating.

Try this aioli with our Stone Crab claws for a match made in seaside heaven. It’s light yet flavorful, adding a zesty kick that highlights the crab's natural sweetness without overpowering it. A dollop on top, and you're not just eating — you're on a culinary voyage.

The Bottom Line

Wrapping up our culinary cruise through the world of crab sauces, we've dipped our toes (and claws) into flavors that span the globe, from the comforting embrace of Classic Melted Butter to the adventurous zest of Herby Lemon-Basil Aioli. 

At George Stone Crab, it's our joy to bring these flavors to your table, pairing our freshly caught Stone Crab claws with sauces that sing of the sea. Here's to meals that turn into memories, where every bite is a discovery and every sauce a journey. 

Cheers to your next seaside feast; may it be as boundless as the ocean itself.


Sauces, spices, and condiments | PCM

Is Spicy Food Good for You? | Cleveland Clinic

Which is better: Salty, Sweet, or Sour | Chasing the Storm

How To Tell When Avocado Is Ripe | Memory Morsels

Sign up now for discounts!